
Plain
Our foundation. Crisp outside, chewy in.
The Bagel Lineup

Our foundation. Crisp outside, chewy in.

Poppy, sesame, garlic, onion, salt. The complete package.

Coated in toasted sesame seeds.

Covered in poppy seeds. Classic deli style.

Coarse sea salt. Simple, direct, essential.

Toasted garlic in every bite.

Toasted onion, savory and sharp.

Dark, earthy, and slightly sweet.

Classic rye, deli style.

Hearty whole grain with a seeded crust.

Wheat dough with a touch of honey.

A little tang, same chewy bite.

Rich, golden egg dough. Soft and slightly sweet.

Egg dough with the everything topping.

Cheddar and jalapeño with a little heat.

Sweet, hearty, breakfast defined.

Blueberries baked into every bagel.

Blueberry bagel with a sweet crumb topping.

Chocolate chips in a lightly sweet dough.

Sweet and cinnamony, like breakfast in a bagel.

Cookies and cream, baked right on.

Topped with Fruity Pebbles cereal.

Swirled in every color of the rainbow.
LimitedPink, sweet, and strawberry through and through.
Skip the line. Order ahead from our Jackson flagship and pick up when ready.
Order NowWe supply wholesale bagels to restaurants, cafés, and hotels across NJ, NY, and PA.
Wholesale InfoAll Star Bagels has been hand-rolling and baking bagels at our Jackson flagship on Bennetts Mills Road since 1994. Our menu includes over 25 traditional and specialty flavors baked fresh every morning, including classic favorites like Everything, Plain, and Sesame, sweet varieties like Blueberry and Cinnamon Raisin, savory specialties like Jalapeño Cheddar and Egg Everything, fun ones like Rainbow and Fruity Pebble, and rotating seasonal flavors throughout the year. Order online for pickup, stop in daily from 6 AM, or contact us at (732) 276-5217 for catering and large orders.