The Bagel Lineup

Every bagel we bake.

25+ flavors, hand-rolled and baked fresh every morning at our Jackson flagship. Available for online pickup or in-store daily from 6 AM.

Order Online for Pickup Visit the Jackson Shop
  • Plain

    Plain

    Our foundation. Crisp outside, chewy in.

  • Everything

    Everything

    Poppy, sesame, garlic, onion, salt. The complete package.

  • Sesame

    Sesame

    Coated in toasted sesame seeds.

  • Poppy

    Covered in poppy seeds. Classic deli style.

  • Salt

    Coarse sea salt. Simple, direct, essential.

  • Garlic

    Toasted garlic in every bite.

  • Onion

    Toasted onion, savory and sharp.

  • Pumpernickel

    Dark, earthy, and slightly sweet.

  • Whole Wheat

    Hearty whole wheat, same chewy bite.

  • Rye

    Classic rye, deli style.

  • Cinnamon Raisin

    Sweet, hearty, breakfast defined.

  • Marble

    Plain and pumpernickel swirled together.

  • Asiago Cheese

    Topped with baked Asiago cheese.

  • Jalapeño Cheddar

    Cheddar and jalapeño with a little heat.

  • Sun-Dried Tomato

    Sun-dried tomato baked right in.

  • Egg

    Rich, golden egg dough. Soft and slightly sweet.

  • Egg Everything

    Egg dough with the everything topping.

  • Blueberry

    Blueberries baked into every bagel.

  • Chocolate Chip

    Chocolate chips in a lightly sweet dough.

  • French Toast

    Sweet and cinnamony, like breakfast in a bagel.

  • Cinnamon Sugar

    Dusted with cinnamon sugar.

  • Apple Cinnamon

    Apple and cinnamon, warm and sweet.

  • Seasonal

    Pumpkin Spice

    Fall in a bagel. Available September through November.

  • Seasonal

    Cranberry Orange

    Tart cranberry and bright orange.

  • Seasonal

    Maple Walnut

    Maple sweetness with toasted walnuts.

Order online for pickup.

Skip the line. Order ahead from our Jackson flagship and pick up when ready.

Order Now ›

Ordering for a business?

We supply wholesale bagels to restaurants, cafés, and hotels across NJ, NY, and PA.

Wholesale Info ›

Fresh bagels made daily in Jackson, NJ.

All-Star Bagel has been hand-rolling and baking bagels at our Jackson flagship on Bennetts Mills Road since 1994. Our menu includes over 25 traditional and specialty flavors baked fresh every morning, including classic favorites like Everything, Plain, and Sesame, sweet varieties like Blueberry and Cinnamon Raisin, savory specialties like Asiago Cheese and Jalapeño Cheddar, and rotating seasonal flavors throughout the year. Order online for pickup, stop in daily from 6 AM, or contact us at (732) 276-5217 for catering and large orders.