Family-Owned · Jackson, NJ · Since 1994

A Jackson bagel shop, three decades in the making.

A pile of fresh sesame, poppy and plain bagels

The All Star Bagels shop on Bennetts Mills Road in winter

Where it started

It started in 1994 on Bennetts Mills Road.

All Star Bagels opened in 1994 at 665 Bennetts Mills Road in Jackson, New Jersey, as a small-town bagel spot. It quickly became a neighborhood staple, known for bagels that are hand-rolled, boiled, and baked fresh every morning.

More than 25 years later, the flagship is still on Bennetts Mills Road, and All Star Bagels is still family-owned.

80M+

Bagels later.

Over 80 million bagels later, All Star Bagels has grown from one Jackson shop to 15+ locations across New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Through recessions, supply chain disruptions, and three decades of changing breakfast trends, the recipe never changed.

What we make

Bagels, breakfast, and then some.

Bagels

25+ flavors, from plain, sesame, and everything to seasonal favorites like Strawberry, Pumpkin Pie, and Cranberry Orange. Made fresh daily.

Breakfast

Made-to-order breakfast sandwiches like the Grand Slam, Triple Play, and the SLIDER, with Boar's Head deli meat.

Lunch and coffee

Lunch options, fresh brewed coffee, specialty lattes, and cold brew.

Catering

A dozen for the office or a spread for a family gathering. Call the Jackson flagship to order.

What's next

The next chapter.

We now supply wholesale bagels to restaurants, cafés, and hotels across New Jersey, New York, and Pennsylvania.

We're also building a list of operators interested in bringing All Star Bagels to new markets. Join the expansion interest list.

Visit the Jackson flagship